Decision of the Week takes a recent Arizona appellate decision and explains what it means for people going through divorce, custody, and support cases, and for the attorneys who handle them.
In short: if your prenuptial agreement includes a written waiver of financial disclosure, it will be very hard to undo later. And the safety valve for a spouse who waived spousal maintenance is narrow.
The Case in Brief
Fadlon v. Cleverly is a published opinion from Division One of the Arizona Court of Appeals, decided 3/6/2026. Six weeks before the wedding, the wife signed a prenuptial agreement that her fiancé’s father had prepared. She didn’t have her own attorney. The agreement waived spousal maintenance, and it included an express written waiver of any further financial disclosure.
When the marriage ended, the superior court found the agreement enforceable and denied spousal maintenance. The wife argued the waiver should be set aside under an Arizona statute that protects a spouse who would otherwise end up eligible for public assistance. The court disagreed, and she appealed.
What the Court Decided
The prenup was enforceable. In Arizona, a voluntarily signed, written prenup is enforceable unless the spouse challenging it proves two things: (1) it was unconscionable when signed, and (2) before signing, they didn’t get fair and reasonable disclosure of the other party’s property and debts, didn’t waive that disclosure in writing, and didn’t otherwise have adequate knowledge of it. The wife had signed a written waiver of further disclosure. That ended the challenge. As the court put it: “This voluntary and express written waiver defeats her claim that the PMA is unenforceable.”
The court laid out how to override a maintenance waiver. Arizona law lets a court order support despite a prenup waiver if enforcing the waiver would leave a spouse eligible for public assistance. The requesting spouse must first show eligibility for public assistance. The court then generally decides whether, without the waiver, that spouse would qualify for maintenance under the Arizona Spousal Maintenance Guidelines. The requesting spouse also has to show what amount is needed to avoid public-assistance eligibility. The Guidelines amount is the ceiling. And even if every showing is made, the court can still enforce the waiver.
Here, the wife’s public benefits had been tied to having the children in her care, and she no longer had custody at trial. She offered no evidence that she’d be eligible for public assistance on her own, or of the amount needed to avoid it. The waiver stood.
What It Means for You
If you’re about to sign a prenup, keep these points in mind:
- Read the disclosure provisions. A clause waiving further financial disclosure can block a later challenge to the entire agreement, even if you weren’t shown the full picture (in Fadlon, that included trust interests of undetermined value).
- Get your own attorney, and start early. Courts look at the conditions under which an agreement was signed, including whether each person had independent counsel and time to review it. Fixing a problem before the wedding costs far less than litigating it in a divorce.
- Don’t count on the public-assistance exception. It’s narrow. A spouse who waived maintenance has to prove eligibility for public assistance and the amount needed to avoid it, and the court still isn’t required to override the waiver.
Learn more about prenuptial and postnuptial agreements and spousal maintenance in Arizona.
For Attorneys
Fadlon v. Cleverly, ___ Ariz. ___, 588 P.3d 668 (App. 2026) (published opinion).
- Prenuptial agreement enforceability: ¶ 29 (§ 25-202(C) standard); ¶¶ 30–31 (procedural and substantive unconscionability factors); ¶¶ 32–33 (express written waiver of disclosure defeats inadequate-disclosure challenge).
- § 25-202(D) override of a maintenance waiver: ¶¶ 3, 36 (framework); ¶ 37 (Guidelines amount is the ceiling; court retains discretion to decline); ¶¶ 39–40 (application).
- Appellate jurisdiction: ¶¶ 19–25 (a pre-decree ruling that a premarital agreement is enforceable resolves an issue, not a claim, and cannot properly be certified under Rule 78(b), Ariz.R.Fam.L.P.; it may be challenged in a timely appeal from the decree); ¶ 27 (fee award not appealable until entitlement and amount are both determined).
- Also addressed: ¶¶ 45–48 (preclusion of untimely disclosed evidence in parenting matters); ¶ 51 (on-the-record ability-to-pay determination required before allocating the cost of a court-ordered evaluation under Rule 95(a), Ariz.R.Fam.L.P.).
Haney Legal handles family law appeals and works with trial attorneys on appellate issues.
Questions About Your Agreement?
Whether you’re about to sign a prenup or one is being enforced against you, I’m happy to review it with you. Schedule a consultation or call (602) 730-1868.
This article provides general information about Arizona law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.