Decision of the Week takes a recent Arizona appellate decision and explains what it means for people going through divorce, custody, and support cases, and for the attorneys who handle them.
In short: If you’ve appeared in a divorce case, you’re entitled to notice before a default hearing. A default decree entered without that notice is void, and it can be challenged even years later.
The Case in Brief
Simonelic v. Simonelic is a memorandum decision from Division One of the Arizona Court of Appeals, decided 11/10/2026. Wife filed for divorce in 2021. Husband completed the court-ordered parent information program and filed his certificate. Wife then amended her petition to request spousal maintenance, and the court allowed her to serve Husband by email. Husband emailed the judge’s assistant to ask how to file a response, but he never filed one.
Wife applied for a default. The application was emailed to Husband, but it was mailed to two old addresses she knew he no longer used. In January 2022, the court held a default hearing without giving Husband notice and entered a default decree awarding Wife $1,800 a month in spousal maintenance for five years and $1,376 a month in child support. In 2025, Husband asked the court to set aside both the default and the decree. The court denied both requests, and he appealed.
What the Court Decided
Husband waived his objection to service. Completing the parent information program and emailing the court about filing a response counted as appearing in the case. As the court put it: “Husband’s appearance in the case waived any objection he may have had to the method of service.”
The default itself stood. The application for default wasn’t mailed to Husband’s last known address, as the rules require. That defect didn’t matter here. The application was emailed to his current email address, so he had actual notice of it.
The decree was void. Because Wife asked for child support and spousal maintenance, the court had to hold a default hearing before entering judgment. A party who has appeared must get written notice of that hearing at least three days in advance. Husband got none. The court held: “Because Husband did not receive the requisite three-day notice of the default hearing, the Default Decree is void.” A void judgment can be challenged at any time, so the six-month deadline that usually applies to these motions didn’t bar Husband’s request. The court vacated the decree and sent the case back.
This is a memorandum decision, so it isn’t binding precedent. It still shows how the Court of Appeals applies the default rules.
What It Means for You
If you’re involved in a divorce case, keep these points in mind:
- Don’t ignore the case. Small steps, like completing the parent class or emailing the court, can count as appearing. That can waive objections you might otherwise have had to how you were served.
- File a response on time. Husband’s default stayed in place even after four years and an appeal. Filing a response at the start costs far less than trying to undo a default later.
- If you’re the one seeking a default, follow the notice rules. Skipping the notice of the default hearing can leave you with a decree that’s void, along with years of support orders built on it.
Learn more about divorce and changing or enforcing existing orders in Arizona.
For Attorneys
Simonelic v. Simonelic, No. 1 CA-CV 26-0080 FC (Ariz. Ct. App. Nov. 10, 2026) (mem. decision). Citable only for persuasive value under Ariz. R. Sup. Ct. 111(c).
- Default hearing required: ¶ 12 (a petition requesting child support and spousal maintenance requires a default hearing before judgment, citing Rule 44.1(d), Ariz.R.Fam.L.P.).
- Waiver of service objection: ¶¶ 27–29 (general appearance waives an objection to service; completing the parent information program, filing the certificate, and emailing the judicial assistant about a response was a general appearance).
- Rule 44 mailing defect: ¶¶ 32–35 (application not mailed to last known mailing address, but actual notice by email kept the entry of default effective).
- Void default decree: ¶¶ 38–39 (no three-day written notice of the default hearing to a party who appeared, Rule 44.2(b), Ariz.R.Fam.L.P.; decree void, citing BYS Inc. v. Smoudi, 228 Ariz. 573, 578, ¶ 20 (App. 2012)); ¶ 40 (void judgment may be challenged at any time; Rule 85 six-month limit, excusable neglect, prompt action, and meritorious defense do not apply).
Haney Legal handles family law appeals and works with trial attorneys on appellate issues.
Questions About a Default?
Whether you’ve been served with divorce papers or a default decree has been entered against you, I’m happy to review it with you. Schedule a consultation or call (602) 730-1868.
This article provides general information about Arizona law and is not legal advice. Reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship.